Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Sunday, July 13, 2008

Morality Play

This is the discussion I had with myself while completing the Morality Play game.

The fourth question was the famous Vulcan saying, "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few...or the one." Do you uphold it? Now, I say it depends. If by "harm," you mean bodily or psychologically (i.e., creating disposable androids to fight our wars), then NO. I consider that close to, if not already, slavery. If by "harm," you mean you have to go a little bit more out of your way to live life in order for others to have an easier time (i.e., being environmentally conscious and conservative so future generations (your children!) can use the beauties of the planet, too), then YES. I suppose I'll go with..."no"...to answer the question and see what they do with it.

The sixth question talked about being morally responsible for a man's blindness if you didn't donate 10 UK pounds to a charity that helps blind people by paying for medical ways to overcome blindness. I said, "Partly Responsible." Not wholly responsible, becuase then you could ratchet the thing up to you need to donate the thousands needed for a liver transplant and if you don't, you're immoral. Not "not responsible," because, come on, people--if you can buy a cocktail with the money, donate your cocktail fund to the charity.

Wooo! The next question dealt with donating a kidney (oooo, clarivoyance!) to a stranger versus to a relative. I said no difference. Why? It's almost like donating one of your twin children to a childless couple. I mean, assuming neither child comes into harm, and, okay, the difference might be the psychological impact--but seriously...it was rightfully yours to begin with...Maybe this is horrifying to people, but I retain my right to my body and its respective parts.

Question nine discussed morally obligation to your community over other communities, i.e. famine. My first response would be the one you hear on airplane safety instructions: take care to ensure that your oxygen mask is correctly fitted before moving on to help others. This is probably said mostly to avoid being sued, but my point would be you can't really help others if you're dead! But when this applies to communities, I'd say there is no difference. There is no reason you should choose the starving Americans over the starving Africans. They're both peoples, so help them BOTH! Sheesh...

Question twelve dealt with the Vulcan saying once more, but this time, with a painful twist for me. "You can save the lives of ten innocent people by killing one other innocent person. Are you morally obliged to do so?" If you say yes, you just killed an innocent person. If you say no, you just killed ten innocent people. From my heart, I have to say yes, but ever so painfully. Painful like when Frodo ditched Sam in Mordor. Painful like...utter betrayal of the self.

Question thirteen is interesting to me at the moment. "You see an advertisement from a charity in a newspaper about a person in severe need in India. You can help this person at little cost to yourself. Are you morally obliged to do so?" It's definitely off those television commercials about supporting a child. Do I support a child with ten cents a day? Nope. Did I answer the question "strongly obliged"? Yep. I plan to, once I've started living on my own with my own control of my money. As for right now, my parents oversee my money. Actually, it's more money they're put aside for me than money I've earned myself. So I don't feel like I should donate my money until it's wholly "my" money.

Question fifteen: "A situation arises where you can either save your own child from death or contact the emergency services in order to save the lives of ten other children. You cannot do both, and there is no way to save everyone. Which course of action are you morally obliged to follow?" Oh Fuck. Would I? Would I? Would I? ...I'd have to say "save ten children" while crying. No, I don't have children yet, and yeah, my opinion might change by then, but now, looking deep down...painfully "save ten children."

The final question is judging the morality of war: "You can save the lives of a million innocent people by killing a hundred thousand others. Are you morally obliged to do so?" But it's like before...What do you say, are you Vulcan or not? Do I support war? No, I would prefer it never happened at all. But if it did? Yes... Granted, of course, I have not served in the armed forces, and other than reading about the Iraq war, I haven't ever really been affected by any wars. So, I'm possibly quite cold-hearted and naive about this. Your thoughts?

My moral framework analysis, summed up by the test:
Your Moral Parsimony Score is 88%

What does this mean?

Moral frameworks can be more or less parsimonious. That is to say, they can employ a wide range of principles, which vary in their application according to circumstances (less parsimonious) or they can employ a small range of principles which apply across a wide range of circumstances without modification (more parsimonious). ...

As a rule of thumb, any score above 75% should be considered indicative of a parsimonious moral framework. However, perhaps a better way to think about this is to see how your score compares to other people's scores.

In fact, your score of 88% is significantly higher than the average score of 64%. This suggests that you have utilised a noticeably smaller range of moral principles than average in order to make judgements about the scenarios presented in this test, and that you have tended to judge aspects of the acts and circumstances depicted here to be morally irrelevant that other people consider to be morally relevant.

We make no judgement about whether moral parsimony is a good or bad thing. Some people will think that on balance it is a good thing and that we should strive to minimise the number of moral principles that form our moral frameworks. Others will suspect that moral parsimony is likely to render moral frameworks simplistic and that an overly parsimonious moral framework will leave us unable to deal with the complexity of real circumstances and acts. We'll leave it up to you to decide who is right.

Your score was calculated by combining and averaging your scores in the four categories that appear below.

Geographical Distance
Your score of 100% is significantly higher than the average score of 72% in this category. The suggestion then is that geographical distance plays little, if any, role in your moral thinking.

Family Relatedness (loyalty and ties)
Your score of 100% is a lot higher than the average score of 52% in this category. It looks as if issues of family relatedness play have no significant role to play in your thinking about moral issues.

Acts and Omissions (acting or avoiding an act)
Your score of 51% is a little lower than the average score of 61% in this category. This suggests that the distinction between acting and omitting to act is sometimes a relevant factor in your moral thinking. Probably, you tend to believe that those who act have a greater moral culpability than those who simply omit to act. If this is what you believe, it decreases the parsimoniousness of your moral framework.

Scale (i.e., murder of one person is more accountable than a war that slaughters countless numbers)
Your score of 100% is significantly higher than the average score of 73% in this category. It seems that scale, as it is described above, is not an important consideration in your moral worldview. But if, contrary to our findings, it is important, then it decreases the parsimoniousness of your moral framework.
Apparently, in question thirteen, they sometimes give you a situation for "India" and sometimes for "Australia." Because visitors to the site for the most part are Canadian, US, or UK, they wanted to see if there was a difference. There was a percent in favor of the Australians, but essentially same diff.

Then they go on to explain statistics of people agreeing with you on each question. #4 had 56% of the other respondents giving the same answer I did, and that was the high percentage of the questions I discussed above. Hmmm, it seems I'm a bit unorthodox...

Battleground God

In Battleground God, they test your rational consistency on God existing. You can take direct hits (logical contradictions), bite bullets (social contradictions), or intellectually survive. I took a hit and bit a bullet. Got a medal of distinction for it, because apparently only 45.78% of the people go through this barely scathed. Then again, you think about it--not many people who read/do philosophy should fail it.
Direct Hit 1

You answered "True" to questions 10 and 14.

10. If, despite years of trying, no strong evidence or argument has been presented to show that there is a Loch Ness monster, it is rational to believe that such a monster does not exist.
14. As long as there are no compelling arguments or evidence that show that God does not exist, atheism is a matter of faith, not rationality.

These answers generated the following response:

You've just taken a direct hit! Earlier you agreed that it is rational to believe that the Loch Ness monster does not exist if there is an absence of strong evidence or argument that it does. No strong evidence or argument was required to show that the monster does not exist - absence of evidence or argument was enough. But now you claim that the atheist needs to be able to provide strong arguments or evidence if their belief in the non-existence of God is to be rational rather than a matter of faith.

The contradiction is that on the first ocassion (Loch Ness monster) you agreed that the absence of evidence or argument is enough to rationally justify belief in the non-existence of the Loch Ness monster, but on this occasion (God), you do not.
Okay, I agree. This was a no-no. Ironically, this is the question most theists-who-think-atheists-are-utterly-wrong-and-should-be-converted choose. Whoops. :)

However, I have issues with the way question 14 was stated. It said "as long as," which to me is like "suppose." Supposing there are no compelling arguments or evidence that show that God does not exist, then yes, I do think atheism would be considered a matter of faith and not rationality. But supposing is not the same as IS. Nor is reality the same as personal reality. *I* think there are compelling arguments and evidence that God (as he is typically defined in JCI tradition) does not exist. Therefore, to *me*, atheism is not a faith matter, but a rationality matter.

I guess that's what I get for answering the question truthfully.
Bitten Bullet 1

You answered "True" to questions 7, and 15.

7. It is justifiable to base one's beliefs about the external world on a firm, inner conviction, even in the absence of any external evidence for the truth of these convictions.
15. The serial rapist Peter Sutcliffe had a firm, inner conviction that God wanted him to rape and murder prostitutes. He was, therefore, justified in believing that he was carrying out God's will in undertaking these actions.

These answers generated the following response:

You've just bitten a bullet! You are consistent in applying the principle that it is justifiable to base one's beliefs about the external world on a firm, inner conviction, regardless of the external evidence, or lack of it, for the truth or falsity this conviction. The problem is that it seems you have to accept that people might be justified in their belief that God could demand something terrible.

This is something many religious people are willing to accept. For example, Kierkegaard believed that it is precisely because Abraham had to contravene established morality to follow God's will and attempt to sacrifice his son which made his act the supreme act of faith.

But as Kierkegaard also stressed, this makes the act incomprehensible from a rational point of view. The rational alternative - that people should require more than such an inner conviction to justify such a belief - is more attractive to most people, but you reject this alternative and bite the bullet.
Once again, I have issue with the second question. I took "He was justified" to mean "it was justifiable for him." Maybe wrong, but that's how I took it. Just because it was justifiable for him doesn't mean it was wrong or right or moral. It just means he came to a conclusion via valid logic.

Plus, I don't see how answering "True" to these questions is almost wrong. I said in #7 it was justifiable to bas one's beliefs on a firm, inner conviction. #15 said Peter had a firm, inner conviction that God wanted him to do something, and then the question asked if this was justifiable. Well...yeAH...to Peter, anyways.

Pfft. I think it proves people underestimate the power of a simple pronoun/word.

... so, how did I answer the other questions? ...

I read the FAQ and stuff after I took the test, which is what you're supposed to do. If you haven't taken the test and are actually up to it, don't read the following until you have. It's better if you go into the test cold--no philosophical warmup or anything, so it's straight from the heart or whatever bodily organ in which you keep your convictions. These were my thoughts while facing each question.

1. God exists. DON'T KNOW
Heh, let me explain. Rationally, I can't actually admit there is no God/Force/Thing/Whatever. In my heart, I *want* to say there is no God. Personally, I'm atheist, but if you want me to be utterly Vulcan about it, I'm agnostic.

2. If God does not exist then there is no basis for morality. FALSE
I HATE this one when used in debates against atheism. Fucking morons.

3. Any being which it is right to call God must be free to do anything. TRUE
Duh. Freedom of thought/action is what makes life life--wordly life or otherwise.

4. Any being which it is right to call God must want there to be as little suffering in the word as is possible. TRUE
Here, I thought the question was going for omnibenevolence, and thought I'd take a hit here for believing in one traditional attribute of the JCI God, but I didn't. But really, I suppose it's a question that would set up for a later contradiction, if there was one. Here you could probably see the difference between "rational me" and "personal me." Rationally, God can want for whatever the fuck he wants; supposing there was one, a benevolent being is what I wish for.

5. Any being which it is right to call God must have the power to do anything. FALSE
Ummm...I could see this connection early on, even though I didn't know #16 existed yet. You can't square a circle--not you, your brother, your friend, nor God. A circle is a concept which self-referentially implies perfect roundness. A square is a concept which self-referentially implies four straight sides and four 90-degree corners. You can't square a circle because there is no such concept.

6. Evolutionary theory maybe false in some matters of detail, but it is essentially true. TRUE
Haha, key word here is "essentially."

7. It is justifiable to base one's beliefs about the external world on a firm, inner conviction, even in the absence of any external evidence for the truth of these convictions. TRUE
Ummm...I've tried proving my existence, and seriously this is about all I can come up with. You?

8. Any being that it is right to call God must know everything that there is to know. FALSE
If God knew everything, he would still now know what it would be like to wonder. Plus, wondering >> omniscience. Whence philosophy...Duh-uh...

9. Torturing innocent people is morally wrong. TRUE
It IS.

10. If, despite years of trying, no strong evidence or argument has been presented to show that there is a Loch Ness monster, it is rational to believe that such a monster does not exist. TRUE
The "years of trying" would be my first point. However, since there is no strong argument against Nessie, it is ALSO rational to believe that she exists (ask any kid/adult-who-still-has-her-inner-kid). But, that was not the question--my other point.

11. People who die of horrible, painful diseases need to die in such a way for some higher purpose. FALSE
Sorry to burst your bubble, but Death does not discriminate.

12. If God exists she could make it so that everything now considered sinful becomes morally acceptable and everything that is now considered morally good becomes sinful. FALSE
Apparently this answer conflicts if you think God is the basis of morality. Kind of follows the question of whether God must obey the laws of logic.

13. It is foolish to believe in God without certain, irrevocable proof that God exists. FALSE
Uh, hello, I respect my religious friends.

14. As long as there are no compelling arguments or evidence that show that God does not exist, atheism is a matter of faith, not rationality. TRUE
Better to see my comment on my direct hit.

15. The serial rapist Peter Sutcliffe had a firm, inner conviction that God wanted him to rape and murder prostitutes. He was, therefore, justified in believing that he was carrying out God's will in undertaking these actions. TRUE
Better to see my comment on my bitten bullet.

16. If God exists she could create square circles and make 1 + 1 = 72. FALSE
See #5.

17. It is justifiable to believe in God if one has a firm, inner conviction that God exists, even if there is no external evidence that God exists. TRUE
I trust my religious friends, too.

...

Anyhows...anybody care to give it a shot and tell me about it?

Philosophical Musings

Been playing in this site, just surfing around and playing philosophical games.

Games:

In Do It Yourself Deity they doubt you can make a perfect God. I did it on the first try, apparently ("Perfectly Free" & "Personal God" as the attributes I selected).

In Battleground God...well, I think that deserves a whole post. Fascinating little game.

I took the game Taboo and it came up puzzling. Literally, the thing said my sense of morality was confusing. It was, I admit, confusing and contradicting all over the place. But I must say, I thought some of the things were disgusting and amoral, but not necessarily warranting punishment. Just more of a "you're sick" feeling than a "you're amoral" feeling attached to the people in the scenarios.

So I decided, since my morality as I know it is a little murky, I should play the Morality Play for try to figure it out. It might want its own post, too.

Still playing and reading over there. Watch for updates. :)